« Ten Days: Single Mom | Main | Frances Friday: Random Countdown Stuff »

August 8, 2007

I guess it all depends on how you define "rainbow"

It has been my experience that just about the most sexist person you will ever meet is a liberal man who believes with all of his blessed heart that sexism is both wrong and that he has totally expunged it from his own brain.

The outright blatant misogynist is a puppy in comparison. You know them, you can see them coming from a mile away and avoid them or, if you so choose, confront them. There is nothing to be done with the liberal male who is convinced he is not a sexist, however; the wall of determined ignorance is impenetrable. They would never say or do anything remotely sexist; they love women!

Before I delve into this week's Hmm subject, let me come clean: I am the whitest person you will ever meet. A facial tissue is a healthy tan in comparison to my skin. There are native Canadians on both sides of my family, but you would never, in a million years, guess it from looking at me, the girl who burns bright red and goes straight back to deathly goth-like pallor without the barest tremor of a stop in brown. I once had a sunburn for two years. Thus, I freely admit that I have no personal experience with this subject, and most of what I have to offer is extrapolated from sexism and learned from conversations with incredibly patient people who do know more about it than I do. I am open to being corrected.

However, it seems to me that the worst thing that ever happened to the civil rights and anti-racism movements was when mainstream society wholeheartedly adopted both the belief that racism is evil, and that it is a personal evil, not a societal one. This has made it all but impossible to have a reasonable and open discussion on the subject. People respond to any suggestion that they may have made a racist remark with vitriol and defensiveness because, instead of hearing "you might want to rethink that sentiment," they hear "you personally are an evil human being who wants to burn brown people to death at the stake."

So I'm going to stand out here on the edge of a limb--it's a slight limb, more of a twig really, and swaying something mighty in this breeze--and say that the most racist person you will ever meet is probably a liberal white person who believes with all of his or her blessed heart that racism is both wrong and that he or she has totally expunged it from his or her own brain.

If that is you, allow me to suggest that this is impossible.

You grew up here too. You grew up in a world where the public representations of visible minorities are dominated by crooks and servants, where the Other is exoticized, where young african-american males are incarcerated at a shocking rate, where a hit sitcom set in New York City can have both no people of colour in the cast and also none in the background among the extras. You grew up here too, where literature is what is written by white people, and music is what is sung by white people, and fashion is what is designed by white people, and art is what is painted or photographed by white people; in short, where white is the default, and where whatever is composed or created by anyone else is considered to be a special subset of culture, and not culture itself. You grew up here too, where a major piece of speculative fiction literature (Ursula le Guin's Earthsea series, populated mostly by brown people) was, when it was translated to film, entirely whitewashed, and every character made white, because the producers and casting agents did not believe white people would go to see a movie with an all-brown cast. (That was, incidentally, only a year or two ago.) You grew up here too. It is simply not possible to grow up here and not absorb, on some level, the attitudes and values that inform this culture.

Try to be someone who can hear "that is racist" in connection with yourself without reacting with anger and defensiveness. That, more than any well-meaning on-going discussions about the state of the blogosphere, and its representativeness or lack thereof, and whether or not the diversity of specific portions of the blogosphere accurately reflects that of society as a whole, will do much more to achieve equality. Try to understand that the question "where are the black/asian/etc. bloggers?" is just as telling as "where are the women bloggers?" Try to understand that when people of colour blog invisibly, on purpose, hiding the colour of their skin, that is because they know that racism is real and present on the parentosphere, even if you don't, and they don't want to have to deal with it.

Is the internet the rainbow connection?

Don't make me laugh.

Hey: Did you know that it's International Blog Against Racism Week?

No? Why not?

~~~~~

(Why yes, I am in a bad mood today, Dear Readers. But, just to bolster my claims a little, allow me to direct you to some fabulous posts by people who have a lot more credibility on this subject than I do:

Angry Black Woman: How Prejudice and Bias Works

Anti-Racist Parent: For anything, but start here: Response to a Transracially Adopting Mother

Rice Daddies: What's Race Got to Do With It)


Posted by Andrea at August 8, 2007 8:40 AM under The World

EMAIL this entry

(comments fields are below this section)











Comments

Because of my use of Second Life for some of my projects, I read a lot of blogs about the program and the experiences of others "in world."

The blog entry I've linked to in my name is one that really struck me because of the way one can, essentially, change race using their avatar, and yet the projections of others will come through clearly. When you are in world as a white girl, then switch to a realistic black skin or asian skin, you then get the experience of being on the receiving end of bigotry, and even fetishism.

Similarly, I don't walk around in real life with a name tag that says 'I am going to synagogue on Friday night and I am an observant Jew' - but I do have a tag in SL that says "Jew of SL" that I occasionally wear - and I do get nasty comments from people in certain regions.

And Finally, A link to an artist who's work I like a lot, and her blog: http://www.carlagirl.net/

Posted by: rachel at August 8, 2007 9:44 AM

Next Comment

Great post on one of my favourite topics. The paragraph that starts 'you grew up here too' simply rocks.

Any white liberal who believes they are free from all racial bias should be made to do the race implicit association test. See: https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/

Posted by: Callie at August 8, 2007 10:49 AM

Next Comment

LeGuin was here on Monday, did I tell you that? She's such a wonderful person. She read from her poetry & at the end the audience (small, this is a small town; maybe 40 people) gave her a standing ovation. Not because of anything she said in particular -- just as an honor to her.

Regarding the topic at hand: I'm as white as can be and live in a town that's 98% white, but even still I was SHOCKED when I saw the pictures from BlogHer. White, all white!

Posted by: Jennifer at August 8, 2007 1:19 PM

Next Comment

I think you're absolutely right. I think it;s a crying shame that so many people spout off about how "liberal" they are, but then would not make the connection that they only have white friends and white business comtacts, and read white authors and watch TV shows and movies featuring an all-white cast.

I know that when I was younger, I did not think much about the lack of other ethnicities on TV and in movies because that's all there was. If all you've ever been given is vanilla, and you have not concept of other varieties, you don't really miss it. As I got older, and was exposed to other people and cultures, I did begin to see that there was this gulf that we, as white people, can never truly understand.

My favorite television show of all time was "Homicide: Life on the Street", and not just beacuse of its stellar acting. It had the most diverse cast of any show on TV, and when held up against some networks, still does. There were body shapes of ALL kinds, and (at least in the beginning) 9/10ths of the cast were not what the networks called "conventionally attractive." But there was such a lot of talent in that group. Such raw excellence. It was real. THEY were real. It still remains as a lesson to a whole generation of filmmakers as an ideal. But NBC gave up on it. They didn't have the guts to stick with a cast that was real and human. They tried to "pretty it up", and it failed miserably.

I think change happens when people promote understanding. And, I thank you for doing your part to help bring that change about.

Posted by: KLee at August 8, 2007 5:22 PM

Next Comment

Fabulous post!

This statement: "However, it seems to me that the worst thing that ever happened to the civil rights and anti-racism movements was when mainstream society wholeheartedly adopted both the belief that racism is evil, and that it is a personal evil, not a societal one." This statement is spot on!

Psychological study after psychological study has shown time after time that the reaction we have to race is automatic and unconscious, even among people of color. To deny that is to deny our humanity. Of course, only by becoming aware of that can we even begin to change society and therein lies the problem, as you so articulately explained.

Posted by: LawyerMama at August 8, 2007 6:22 PM

Next Comment

i've been trying to find language for this all week. you nailed it. especially the sentence quoted above by Lawyer Mama...racism is a societal evil, flat out. society is populated by persons, yes...but whether or not i as an individual decide that "i can't see race" doesn't mean that people aren't regularly and consistently treated as though they have one, and it's not the hegemonic dominant.

great post.

Posted by: Bon at August 8, 2007 6:28 PM

Next Comment

You said - You grew up here too.

Actually, I didn't. I grew up in Australia. A different kettle of fish entirely. What does it say about the blogosphere when someone writes a post assuming only people who grew up in the US will read it?

Is that racist?

I ask the question only because it came to me as I read your post. ;)

Snoskred
http://www.snoskred.org/

Posted by: Snoskred at August 8, 2007 7:26 PM

Next Comment

Good point, Snoskred (and a definite oops on my part)--but I'm Canadian. ;)

Posted by: Andrea at August 8, 2007 7:53 PM

Next Comment

De-lurking here...I've been enjoying your posts for some time now and cheering you on as you move bravely into a new to you world as a single mom.

Good post. Good points. I am a white girl but I have experienced the other side of the coin living in a village in Africa where they hadn't seen a white girl before. And similarly on the Navajo Nation or in the Athabascan village of Beaver. After living in Africa I came to London, UK and I was dressed somewhat African and had tanned really dark...and the fact that (white)people crossed the street to get away from me was a real eye opener. And for me it was temporary, but most people they have to deal with it all their lives.

Posted by: wayfarer scientista at August 8, 2007 8:21 PM

Next Comment

Great post, Andrea. The argument that systemic means we are all part of the system--ALL OF US--cannot be made enough, IMHO.

Posted by: Mad Hatter at August 8, 2007 9:44 PM

Next Comment

Great post.

Posted by: yankee,transferred at August 9, 2007 9:17 AM

Next Comment

Amazingly honest and true post. Thank you speaking up.

Posted by: Ashley at August 9, 2007 10:16 AM

Next Comment

thank you, Andrea. I could not agree more with your points here, and you have articulated this whole issue in much clearer and more convincing terms than I could. The knee-jerk reactions that are taking place in some quarters are really quite surprising to me.

Posted by: joy at August 9, 2007 10:26 AM

Next Comment

Ahhhhh Andrea. You have brilliantly boiled this down the fundamental components and honesty that I aimed for in each post I wrote about this. And each comment.

I keep wanting to quote the bits and portions that really resonated and rung true for me and articulated so eloquently what I believe. But next thing I knew I'd C&Pd pretty much your entire post.

I guess if I allow myself one teensy quote,it would be this:

"Try to be someone who can hear "that is racist" in connection with yourself without reacting with anger and defensiveness. That, more than any well-meaning on-going discussions about the state of the blogosphere, and its representativeness or lack thereof, and whether or not the diversity of specific portions of the blogosphere accurately reflects that of society as a whole, will do much more to achieve equality. Try to understand that the question "where are the black/asian/etc. bloggers?" is just as telling as "where are the women bloggers?" Try to understand that when people of colour blog invisibly, on purpose, hiding the colour of their skin, that is because they know that racism is real and present on the parentosphere, even if you don't, and they don't want to have to deal with it."

Yes.

Thank you for participating in the Hmm this week and for the awesome contribution.

Julie
Ravin' Picture Maven

Posted by: Julie Pippert at August 9, 2007 10:43 AM

Next Comment

Great post, Andrea. I really loved how you expressed your thoughts! And I agree with you!

Posted by: Tere at August 9, 2007 7:40 PM

Next Comment

Go Berserk




Remember Me?